A DANGEROUS BARGAIN
by Erin Cotter
Available September 22
I find myself increasingly drawn to Erin Cotter's work with every new release. By Any Other Name was an interesting story burdened by anachronism, but A Traitorous Heart largely did everything I'd hoped its predecessor would do. And now, A Dangerous Bargain is absolutely magnificent, blending historical flavor, romantic undertones, and fantastic worldbuilding with an unsubtle but extremely timely metaphor.
The novel takes place in 15th century Florence, following young art apprentices Virgil Pitti and Leonardo da Vinci (yes, that one). While Leonardo seems to make his art effortlessly while also sketching impossible machines, Virgil trades away memories and weeks of his life to perfect his work. You see, this version of Florence is filled with angels: uncanny creatures who accept bargains from artists to imbue their art with magic. Virgil has done this quite a lot, whittling his life away to patch up his less than stellar work.
But Virgil has a lot on his mind. When the studio's angel must be put down, he's put in charge of their new angel, whom he names Lupa — and she refuses to accept bargains from him. Meanwhile, the departure of the previous angel means all of Virgil's bargains are null and void, and he feels he has no talent left. Leonardo offers to help him, and the pair prepare to put their bid in to paint Lorenzo de' Medici's wedding portrait... and Virgil discovers that Niccolo, his long-lost older brother, may be alive and working with the House of Medici.
Virgil also has an unspoken crush on Leonardo, but that's a whole other set of problems. Not to mention that, given the time he's spent with Lupa, he's beginning to realize what angels really are.
A Dangerous Bargain is equal parts political intrigue, paranormal drama, and tribute to Dante's Inferno. What stuck out the most to me, though, was how the angels of Florence are a fairly up-front metaphor for the modern rise of generative AI. Artists are pushed by the wealthy and by their studios to use it, whittling their lives away for everything from commissions to (effectively) silly memes. The cost is massive but ignored until it's too late, with the deeper truths of the system being legitimately dire even for people who don't bargain. And as Virgil relies more and more on bargains, he feels his artistic skill stagnating until he becomes unafraid to start fresh and make mistakes again. That isn't all this book is, mind, but it's pretty unapologetic about that particular.
This is absolutely Cotter's best so far, and it's gratifying to see her excel more and more with each new story. A Dangerous Bargain feels like a perfectly mixed cocktail, with each ingredient complementing the others. I can't wait to see what's next.
TEA PAIRING: Letters of Lavender
This lavender bergamot blend may be inspired by love letters rather than art, but it still seems very appropriate for our protagonists. It's also one of my favorite blends from the company, hands down. Use my code KARA15 for 15% off this and more book-inspired teas from Chapters Tea & Co.!
FEATURED CANDLE: Owens' Apothecary
This month's limited-edition candle seems to go with everything. Its blend of herbs and chocolate reminds me of Leonardo and Virgil eating breakfast together and Lupa going out of her way to bring Virgil birthday sweets. Be sure to check out more bookish candles from Frostbeard!