THE FAVORITE GIRL
by Monica Arya
Available now
Monica Arya's new thriller The Favorite Girl kicks off with two separate pages for content warnings: one leading to her website for a full list, and a second checking that you're absolutely sure you want to proceed. And, frankly, that's valid. This book covers some pretty heavy topics - the sort that you can't mention on just about any social media site except Tumblr. It's gruesome, distressing, and upsetting. But it's also a very accurate (if not extremely heightened) story about the knock-on effects of childhood trauma.
Demi has been through a horrible childhood, blaming herself for her older sister's death and struggling to stay fed and alive (all for reasons explored later in the book). A newspaper ad seems to hold a ticket to salvation: a want ad for a housekeeper in the high-end home of Dr. and Mrs. Ivory. After a fortuitous stop-in with the Ivorys' neighbors, Demi makes her way to the home. But what she witnesses goes far beyond normal rich people eccentricities.
The Ivory household has several very strict rules, chief being don't ask questions. But after signing an NDA and being subjected to medical tests, Demi has nothing but questions. And her experiences swing wildly between extremes - being wined and dined by her new employers one moment, and witnessing a brutal murder the next. Before long, the truth becomes apparently: Dr. Ivory is carrying on a heinous business, and Demi has been on their radar for far longer than she realized. With time ticking away and only one confidant by her side, she must decide whether to survive in silence or fight her way out.
The Favorite Girl has central themes of human trafficking laced throughout - both the gritty, nasty version you see on the news and a far more "respectable" version hiding in plain sight. While the imagery and action of the book are something akin to a surrealist art film, with the abuses and criminal activities being heightened, at their core there is a truth to them. That's the part that's most chilling: that even the most ridiculous concepts in these books have a kernel of truth.
This does remind me of another book I reviewed this year that was very much about aesthetic. And, in fact, it's nearly the same aesthetic: bleached-blonde women in pure white. Both gave me the feeling as I was reading that these stories were leaning heavily on image and style in the way a screenplay might. But The Favorite Girl squeaks by on two fronts. Firstly, the focus on aesthetics is lampshaded by Demi herself early on, with her observation that the Ivorys might as well be the Cullens, and her confusion at the sheer whiteness of everything. And secondly, there is an actual reason for the aesthetic, as opposed to the feeling that the author was simply imagining a big-screen version. Demi is a dark-skinned woman in a blatantly white world (literally and racially), pushed to conform or die. While the imagery is very on the nose (the family name is Ivory, after all), it at least serves a solid purpose.
I can't recommend The Favorite Girl to everyone because it's not written for everyone. This is one of those stories about violence and abuse that very much threads a needle. For those who have never experienced trauma, it might be too much; for some who have, it might bring up too many memories. But somewhere in the middle are readers who will find catharsis and perhaps even comfort: the idea that someone else in the world knows what it is to be hurt, betrayed, and disbelieved.
DRINK PAIRING: Elixir of Hydration (Peach)
The Ivory family is very particular about what the girls under their roof eat and drink, but peonies have a haunting presence throughout. Velvet Hammer's new peach Elixir of Hydration has a pop of pale pink color that reminds me of some of the few non-monochrome items throughout the book. Use my code KARA15 for 15% off this and other sparkly elixirs from Velvet Hammer!
FEATURED CANDLE: Snarky Skull
Created as a candle inspired by Bob of The Dresden Files, this pale white candle with its gentle, earthy scent seems like the kind of thing that might almost be allowed in the Ivory mansion. That and... well, Dr. Ivory is an osteopath. And that's all I'll say about that. Check out this and more book-inspired candles from Frostbeard!























