On Generative AI
It is, to say the least, a hot-button topic. And it's one that, as someone who works in a variety of fields affected by the arrival of generative AI, I have to write out my stance on clearly and accessibly. Because, as time goes on, it is going to be more and more essential to draw that line.
So first off, I should be clear about what this blog post isn't. It is not an attempt to change your mind, to make you understand that generative AI as currently utilized and marketed is bad for our brains, bad for the environment, bad for business, and bad for human creativity. If you were unaware of any of these points, the hypertext in the previous sentence will help you learn, and I encourage you to check those links out. But if these are all things you are aware of and you still champion large language models as "progress" (or even as "harmless" or "not great but"), then one middle-aged nerd in the U.S. is not going to change your mind.
If there's one thing this blog post is covering, it's my bases. Because I am a writer. I have books coming out, I review books, and I write for magazines and news websites. Every field I work in is being invaded by large language models, and people are being less and less open about their use thereof, or more and more slipshod with their admissions of use of it.
To that end, I want to be very clear about my stance, if I haven't been already. While I acknowledge the concept of artificial intelligence as useful in research and data processing and figuring out whether Freddy Fazbear is going to jumpscare you, I will never knowingly associate with a project that makes use of generative AI.
"But," say some of you, "you're going to be closing off a lot of creative venues." I sure am. And honestly, I'm probably going to have to step back from several things in the coming months and years. And I'll be sad to do so. But I am more committed to ensuring that I am never involved in the abuse of someone else's copyrighted creative work than I am in maximizing my income streams.
So, breaking it down:
I will never knowingly work with a publisher that allows the use of generative AI in their written work, in their covers, or in their press.
I will never knowingly attend a convention that employs the use of generative AI in its advertising.
I will never knowingly review or promote a book or project that uses generative AI.
I will never knowingly be a part of a project that uses generative AI, and if I discover too late that the project has employed generative AI without my knowledge, I will speak to the people in charge and discern whether they plan to continue using it. If they do, I will part ways with that project, and I will be open about why if asked.
Note that I put "knowingly" in every case. This is because I have ended up seeing generative AI integrated into projects after my portion was done, and without my knowledge. These happened at a time when I wasn't aware just how pervasive this would be, to the point that I would need to establish a stance and write it into any future agreements. Lesson learned. Going forward, this is going to be something I check regularly.
If you discover that a project I am currently active in is currently and actively employing generative AI, please don't hesitate to let me know. Because odds are I don't know about it and I'll want to be told.
With all that said, I'm very happy to say that two publishers I work with regularly - Obverse Books and 18thWall - are both of the same mind. Obverse makes a note of their commitment to human creativity in every book they publish now, and MH Norris of 18thWall spoke out about NaNoWriMo's misguided stance on generative AI and accessibility. I am proud to work with them and honored that they count me among their regular contributors.
I will continue to vet the projects I review, support, and in which I participate. There will be misses along the way, but it's more important to me to stand firm on this. Once this post goes live, I will link it prominently so it's always accessible.
To those of you who continue to value human creativity, thank you. You're keeping something really beautiful alive.
About the Author
0 comments